Carlson frowned some more. “We’re missing something.”
“Look, Nick, let’s not make this more complicated than we have to. We got Beck nailed good on the Schayes murder. It’ll be a righteous collar. Let’s just forget about Elizabeth Beck, okay?”
Carlson looked at him. “Forget about her?”
Stone cleared his throat and spread his hands. “face it. Nailing Beck on Schayes, that’ll be a piece of pie. But his wife—Christ, that case is eight years old. We got some scraps, okay, but we’re not going to get him for it. It’s too late. Maybe”—he gave too dramatic a shrug—“maybe it’s best to let sleeping dogs lie.”
“What the hell are you talking about?”
Stone moved closer and beckoned Carlson to bend down. “Some people at the Bureau would rather we didn’t dig this all up.”
“Who doesn’t want us digging what up?”
“It’s not important, Nick. We’re all on the same side, right? If we find out KillRoy didn’t kill Elizabeth Beck, it just opens a can of worms, right? His lawyer will probably ask for a new trial—”
“They never tried him for Elizabeth Beck.”
“But we wrote her off as KillRoy’s handiwork. It would add doubt, that’s all. It’s neater this way.”
“I don’t want neat,” Carlson said. “I want the truth.”
“We all want that, Nick. But we want justice even more, right? Beck will get a life sentence for Rebecca Schayes. KillRoy will stay in jail. That’s how it should be.”
“There are holes, Tom.”
“You keep saying that, but I don’t see any. You were the one who first came up with Beck being good for his wife’s murder.”
“Exactly,” Carlson said. “For his wife’s murder. Not Rebecca Schayes’s.”
“I don’t get what you mean.”
“The Schayes murder doesn’t fit.”
“You kidding me? It makes it more solid. Schayes knew something. We started closing in. Beck had to shut her up.”
Carlson frowned again.
“What?” Stone continued. “You think Beck’s visit to her studio yesterday—right after we pressured him—was just a coincidence?”
“No,” Carlson said.
“Then what, Nick? Don’t you see? Schayes’s murder fits in beautifully.”
“A little too beautifully,” Carlson said.
“Ah, don’t start with that crap.”
“Let me ask you something, Tom. How well did Beck plan and execute his wife’s murder?”
“Pretty damn well.”
“Exactly. He killed every witness. He got rid of the bodies. If it wasn’t for the rainfall and that bear, we’d have nothing. And let’s face it. Even with that, we still don’t have enough to indict, much less convict.”
“So?”
“So why is Beck suddenly so stupid? He knows we’re after him. He knows that Schayes’s assistant will be able to testify that he saw Rebecca Schayes the day of the murder. So why would he be stupid enough to keep the gun in his garage? Why would he be stupid enough to leave those gloves in his own trash can?”
“Easy,” Stone said. “He rushed this time. With his wife, he had plenty of time to plan.”
“Did you see this?”
He handed Stone the surveillance report.
“Beck visited the medical examiner this morning,” Carlson said. “Why?”
“I don’t know. Maybe he wanted to know if there was anything incriminating in the autopsy file.”
Carlson frowned yet again. His hands were itching for another wash. “We’re missing something, Tom.”
“I don’t see what, but hey, either way, we got to get him into custody. Then we can sort it out, okay?”
Stone headed over to Fein. Carlson let the doubts sink in. He thought again about Beck’s visit to the medical examiner’s office. He took out his phone, wiped it down with a handkerchief, and pressed the digits. When someone answered, he said, “Get me the Sussex County medical examiner.”
29
In the old days—ten years ago anyway—she had friends living at the Chelsea Hotel on West Twenty-third Street. The hotel was half tourist, half residential, all-around kooky. Artists, writers, students, methadone addicts of every stripe and persuasion. Black fingernails, goth-white face paint, bloodred lipstick, hair without a trace of curl—all in the days before it was mainstream.
Little had changed. It was a good place to remain anonymous.
After grabbing a slice of pizza across the street, she’d checked in and had not ventured out of her room. New York. She’d once called this city home, but this was only her second visit in the past eight years.
She missed it.
With too practiced a hand, she tucked her hair under the wig. Today’s color would be blond with dark roots. She put on a pair of wire-rim glasses and jammed the implants into her mouth. They changed the shape of her face.
Her hands were shaking.
Two airplane tickets sat on the kitchen table. Tonight, they would take British Airways Flight 174 from JFK to London’s Heathrow Airport, where her contact would meet them with new identities. Then they would take the train to Gatwick and take the afternoon flight to Nairobi, Kenya. A jeep would take them near the foothills of Mount Meru in Tanzania, and a three-day hike would follow.
Once they were there—in one of the few spots on this planet with no radio, no television, no electricity—they would be free.
The names on the tickets were Lisa Sherman. And David Beck.
She gave her wig one more tug and stared at her reflection. Her eyes blurred, and for a moment, she was back at the lake. Hope ignited in her chest, and for once she did nothing to extinguish it. She managed a smile and turned away.
She took the elevator to the lobby and made a right on Twenty-third Street.
Washington Square Park was a nice walk from here.
Tyrese and Brutus dropped me on the corner of West Fourth and Lafayette streets, about four blocks east of the park. I knew the area well enough. Elizabeth and Rebecca had shared an apartment on Washington Square, feeling deliciously avant garde in their West Village digs—the photographer and the social-working attorney, striving for Bohemia as they mingled with their fellow suburban-raised wanna-bes and trust-fund revolutionaries. Frankly I never quite bought it, but that was okay.
I was attending Columbia Medical School at the time, and technically, I lived uptown on Haven Avenue near the hospital now known as New York Presbyterian. But naturally I spent a lot of time down here.