“Why, are you planning on trying something? Because I can scream really loud.”
The old me would’ve made some comment about getting her sexy ass in my bed to see exactly how loud I could make her scream, but somehow I know she’s not looking for me to be that guy. It’s refreshing. I move closer to her into the cool night air, relieved that I don’t have to put on the smooth guy act.
“Can I join you?” I ask.
She eyes me carefully, her gaze lingering a moment too long. For a second I wonder if she’s going to say no. I can’t remember the last time a girl said no to me. She chews on her lip, trying to read me, then clasps her hands together in her lap. “You can stay, if you behave yourself.”
I chuckle softly. What was she expecting me to do? She either has major trust issues, or she’s caught wind of my reputation. “Do you have mace on you? Maybe a rape whistle tucked under your shirt?”
Her eyes narrow slightly. “Ha, ha,” she says dryly.
I sink to the bottom step beside her and suddenly question what the hell I’m doing out here with her. This girl is sure as f**k too sweet for me to mess around with. But I know that isn’t what I want tonight. If it was, I’d be upstairs in my bedroom with the blond from earlier, and maybe her brunette friend too.
“I’m Jase.” I extend my hand toward her.
She looks at it, but makes no move to give me hers.
“I’ll just call you Whistle if you don’t tell me your name.”
Her eyes are still blazing on mine as she straightens her shoulders. “If you’re trying to pick me up, save us both the time. My answer’s no.”
My shoulders vibrate with a soft laugh. “Pretty sure of yourself, aren’t you, Whistle? I wasn’t going to ask you out, but your little speech was cute.”
She fixes her mouth in a tight line. “My name’s Avery.”
I’ve never met an Avery. The name is pretty, and unique – just like her. Her makeup is natural, subtle compared to the high sheen gloss of the blond’s lips from earlier. She’s pretty but not overdone.
“I haven’t seen you here before.”
“That’s because I don’t typically come to these things.”
She picks up her cup of beer, but doesn’t drink from it. It’s like she needs something to do with her hands. I know the feeling. I feel oddly clumsy and unsure around her – not something I’m used to.
I don’t need to ask why she doesn’t come to frat parties. It’s obvious this isn’t her scene. “Do you need another drink?”
She shakes her head. “Who am I kidding? I’m not going to drink this.” She dumps the contents of the cup into the grass before setting the empty cup beside her.
“Not a fan of beer? I think I could find you something else if you want it…”
“I’m not a fan of drinking, really.” Her voice is soft, like there’s some faraway memory pulling at her attention.
Now that I’ve turned to face her, I can’t look away. Her eyes are a mesmerizing shade of green and her hair looks faintly red when it catches the light. She has soft, delicate features, high cheek bones, a full mouth and pretty wide-set eyes. She’s lovely.
I drag a hand through my hair and turn away because I can’t seem to stop f**king staring at her. Stop being a creep, Jase. Instead I look out into the backyard – littered with red plastic cups, beer bottles and cigarettes butts.
“Why not?”
“It makes you do stupid things,” Avery says after several long moments.
I simply nod. She has no idea how close to home that statement hits. Did she do stupid things in her past, or is she basing that on the actions of the people inside?
“Why are you out here?” she asks.
“I needed some air. What about you?”
“The same, I guess.” She attempts a smile, but I can tell she’s just as out of practice at it as I am.
There’s something sad about her eyes, and it makes me want to kick the ass of whoever put that look there. Was it some drunk jerk that hurt her? Maybe that’s why she doesn’t like alcohol.
“I took last semester off,” I say, trying to keep the conversation going. “And even though I live in a frat house, I guess I’m not ready for the start of the new semester party.”
She looks over at me. “You’re a Delta Sig?”
I nod, glad that she doesn’t ask why I took last semester off.
She looks back out into the yard and releases a deep sigh.
This girl is different, and I’m completely thrown off my game. But I kind of like it. She refuses to drool all over me, and I respect her for that. I hate when girls who know nothing about me act as if we’re freaking soul mates. It’s such a turn off. But Avery seems different. I want to know her.
Avery
Jase remains silent beside me, and I can sense there’s something more on his mind than just escaping the party inside – only I have no idea what it is, or why he’s chosen me as company. I grin to myself thinking Madison will be proud that I’m out here talking to the Pretty Boy. And pretty, he is. It’s almost too much to handle having him this close and personal. He smells freakin’ incredible too, like a hint of spicy cologne and a trace of laundry detergent. I want to bury my nose in his neck and inhale, get closer to that delicious scent. Of course I do no such thing.
“What’s the most interesting thing about you?” he asks suddenly.
I am so not telling him that. His question is an odd one, but I go with it. “I was adopted.”